A brand new well being examine exhibits COVID-19 vaccination lottery packages, reminiscent of Louisiana’s “Shot At a Million,” produced negligible outcomes regardless of tens of millions in taxpayer-funded giveaways.
Printed by the Journal of the American Medical Affiliation (JAMA), the examine examined vaccination charges throughout the 19 states that introduced vaccine lotteries by July 1 and in contrast them with states that didn’t have vaccine lotteries.
Researchers used state-level COVID-19 vaccination knowledge from Johns Hopkins College between April 28 and July 1, a interval when vaccines had been broadly obtainable and information reviews had been selling the motivation packages.
Gov. John Bel Edwards introduced Louisiana’s $2.3 million lottery program June 17.
Whereas controlling for numerous elements, the examine concluded the affiliation between COVID-19 lotteries and vaccination charges “had been very small in magnitude and statistically indistinguishable from zero.”
“No statistically vital affiliation was detected between a cash-drawing announcement and the variety of vaccinations earlier than or after the announcement date, a interval that included bulletins of lottery winners for many lottery states,” examine authors stated.
An earlier examine from July 2 that examined Ohio’s “Vax-a-Million” lottery, the primary within the nation, decided such packages probably wouldn’t improve “vaccine uptake.”
“Subsequently, the sources dedicated to vaccine lotteries could also be extra efficiently invested in packages that focus on underlying causes for vaccine hesitancy and low vaccine uptake,” stated Allan J. Walkey, a doctor at Boston Medical Heart and a professor of medication.
“It is very important rigorously consider methods designed to extend vaccine uptake, quickly deploy profitable methods, and part out these that don’t work,” Walkey stated.
Louisiana’s “Shot At a Million” program awarded $100,000 every week from July 14 to Aug. 4, 9 $100,000 scholarships for kids age 12-17 and a grand prize of $1 million Aug. 6.
Per week after the grand prize drawing, a separate $7.5 million vaccine incentive program known as “Shot for 100” was introduced. The initiative supplied faculty college students $100 for his or her first vaccine dose.
“Shot for 100” was expanded earlier this month to incorporate any vaccine eligible resident of Louisiana. It is scheduled to finish on Saturday.